This Gatorskin flapper is made of high-quality anitoxidant material to resist chloramine and harsh water conditions. It seals tightly with every flush.

Fits virtually all flush valves, including "Tilt" models

Eliminates the need for guide arms and upper and lower lift wires

Heavy-duty stainless steel chain

Individually boxed for maximum protection

Box includes supporting platform so flapper keeps its shape

Out Of Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$5.08

0 Available

Wolverine Brass

Model #: 51162

SKU: 51162

Wolverine Brass 51162 Big Orange Vinyl Extreme Tank Flapper, Orange

Specially formulated orange vinyl material designed to withstand EXTREME water conditions

Built-in overflow tube adapter included

Fits all standard 2" plastic and brass flush valves

Stainless "no kink" chain assembly

In Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Compare

13,089 Available

American Standard

Model #: 7381129-200-0070A

SKU: 40016

738159-0070A Flapper Assembly For American Standard Cadet Toilets

In Stock

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$24.79

153 Available

Korky

Model #: 52BAG

SKU: 51169

Korky Flapper 52X- Economy (Blue)

Flapper is made of durable, high grade vinyl

In Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$4.43

2,457 Available

Wolverine Brass

Model #: 51164

SKU: 51164

Wolverine Brass 51164 Big Orange Premium Tank Flapper, Orange

Heavy Wolverine rubber, yet flexible enough for positive seal

Stainless no kink chain assembly

Antioxidant treated silicone orange rubber resists deterioration

Built-in overflow tube adapter included

In Stock

Substitution Available

Compare

855 Available

Kohler

Model #: GP85160

SKU: 40326

Blue Flapper with Float

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$9.43

90 Available

Rubber Replacement Flapper For Kohler, Briggs, & Other Slant Flush Valves

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 80011

Rubber Replacement Flapper For Kohler, Briggs, & Other Slant Flush Valves

Kohler replacement flapper, made of quality WB rubber, fits Kohler, Briggs, & other slant flush valves

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$7.23

183 Available

Wolverine Brass

Model #: 57733

SKU: 57733

Wolverine Brass 57733 Big Orange II Hard Plastic Flapper, Orange

Big Orange II Flapper for Big Orange Harsh Water Flush Valve

Big Orange chloramine resistant materials that will last in harsh water

Saves money by ending flush valve water leaks

Removable refill tube holder for E-Z height

In Stock

Substitution Available

Compare

97 Available

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper without Adapter

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 40015

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper without Adapter

Eliminates guide arms, upper and lower wires

Fits most conventional closets

Made of "Tuff-Flex" rubber, which will not warp

Molded in one piece

Contractor quality

5 year guarantee

Made in USA

In Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$3.92

271 Available

Black Rubber Replacement Flapper For Crane

PlumbMaster Approved

Model #: 51218W

SKU: 51218W

Black Rubber Replacement Flapper For Crane

Crane replacement flapper, fits a Crane flush valve, made of quailty, black rubber, includes a 9" stainless steel chain

Regular rubber flapper replaces Crane* style #57

Made of high quality black rubber

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$6.64

110 Available

Blue Vinyl Ultra Blue Star Flapper for Coast

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 40282

Blue Vinyl Ultra Blue Star Flapper for Coast

Superior seal technology

Replaces Coast 53376

Also fits Kohler

In Stock

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$3.05

3,252 Available

Korky

Model #: 54BP

SKU: 40291

Korky Original Toilet Flapper

The Korky 2" Toilet Tank Flapper features rubber construction. The flapper is universal and fits 2" plastic flush valves. This original toilet flapper is the choice of plumbing pros since 1954. Made of flexible rubber for a tight seal.

Stainless steel hook and chain

Original tank ball toilet flapper introduced in 1954

1-year warranty

Made in USA

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$4.67

128 Available

Fluidmaster

Model #: 501P21

SKU: 40331

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye 501P21 Red Microban Dura-Flush Flapper, 2" Valve Opening

Easy to Install and works on most toilets. Material engineered to resist chlorine. Universal Fit, rigid frame aligns the flapper and seals the drain every time. Removable adapter ring allows easy attachment to flush valves with our with out mounting ears.

Has Built-In Microban that helps fight flapper breakdown due to bacteria

5-years warranty

Chlorine-resistant flapper for harsh water regions

Fits on flush valves with or without mounting ears

Rigid frame aligns flapper on drain

Outlasts vinyl or rubber

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$5.46

56 Available

Korky

Model #: 16X

SKU: 51167

Korky Flapper 16X- 1.6 Tank

The adjustable water-saver saves up to 50% more water when used in conventional toilets

In Stock

Inventory Details

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$9.52

39 Available

Rubber Universal Flapper and Chain without Adapter

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 40011

Rubber Universal Flapper and Chain without Adapter

Eliminates guide arms, upper and lower wires

Fits most conventional closets

Made of high quality rubber

5 year guarantee

Made in USA

In Stock

Inventory Details

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$3.83

76 Available

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 40010

Rubber Universal Flapper with Adapter

Eliminates guide arms, upper and lower wires

Made of high quality rubber

Fits most conventional closets

Made in USA

5 year guarantee

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$4.11

1,487 Available

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper with Adapter

PlumbMaster Approved

Model #: 40003

SKU: 40003

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper with Adapter

Eliminates guide arms, upper and lower wires

Made of Tuff-Flex Rubber

Fits most conventional closets

Contractor quality

Molded in one piece

Made in USA

5 year guarantee

In Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$4.41

516 Available

71706 Blue Rubber Flapper Replacement Positive Seal Ring For Kohler/Coast

PlumbMaster Approved

SKU: 40194

71706 Blue Rubber Flapper Replacement Positive Seal Ring For Kohler/Coast

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$1.23

559 Available

Fluidmaster

Model #: B502P10

SKU: 80898W

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye Adjust-A-Flush B502P10 Thermoplastic Flapper

Fluidmaster® No. B502P10, Bulls Eye® Adjust-A-Flush Flapper, Contractor Pack, 10 to a Pack

All the benefits of the Bull's eye and super flapper

Dials to adjust volume for a custom flush

Easy to adjust after installation

Rigid frame for better alignment

Floating chain eliminates old wires and guides

5-years warranty

In Stock

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$8.27

246 Available

Fluidmaster

Model #: B501P10

SKU: 80897

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye B501LP10 Thermoplastic Super Flapper without Adapter

Fluidmaster® No. B501P10, Bulls Eye® Super Flapper, Contractor Pack, 10 to a Pack

All the benefits of the Bull's eye flapper

Chlorine-resistant flapper for harsh water regions

Outlast vinyl or rubber, won't rot or corrode

Rigid frame for better alignment

Floating chain eliminates old wires and guides

5-years warranty

In Stock

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$5.90

423 Available

Hydro-Force Silicone Rubber Adjustable Premium Flapper

Next By Danco

Model #: HFL190

SKU: 40183

Hydro-Force Silicone Rubber Adjustable Premium Flapper

Unique in the market for its full range of adjustability, the hydro-force 2". Adjustable flapper accurately fits more toilets than any other flapper sold. This leak resistant, easily adjusted, water-saving product takes the guesswork out of choosing the right flapper. The Hydro-Force is made of high-quality materials that can withstand the extreme water conditions and harsh chemicals that cause leaks.

Float adjusts easily to help save water and includes a stainless steel chain

Silicone rubber construction is corrosion resistant in harsh water conditions

Great range of water level adjustability

Float can nest in the flapper to help maximize flush

Includes a stainless steel chain

Replaces 2" 1.6 and 3.5 gpf flappers

Corrosion and chlorine resistant

In Stock

Inventory Details

Substitution Available

Orders over $149 ship FREE*

Compare

$9.58

288 Available

PRODUCT(S) ADDED TO CART

1(current)
2
3

You have 1 out of 5 products to compare selected.

Clear All

Add Item

Add x

Hide Show

Product Availability by Store Location

Previous Next

- from stores found

Hours

SHOPPING

Products
Brands
Programs
Services
Industries
Resources

SUPPORT

My Account
Contact Us
Shipping & Delivery
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Import Saved Cart
Warranty

ABOUT US

Our Company
Careers
Feedback

Special Deals & New Products

Join our mailing list to stay up-to-date on the latest products and deals!

Download the PlumbMaster App

apple-store

Need Help? Call Customer Service 1-800-523-5130

Shop by Brand

Shop by Price

Shop by Sub Brand

Shop by Type

Shop by Flow Rate

Flappers

Gatorskin Premium Flapper (Boxed)

Wolverine Brass 51162 Big Orange Vinyl Extreme Tank Flapper, Orange

738159-0070A Flapper Assembly For American Standard Cadet Toilets

Korky Flapper 52X- Economy (Blue)

Wolverine Brass 51164 Big Orange Premium Tank Flapper, Orange

Blue Flapper with Float

Rubber Replacement Flapper For Kohler, Briggs, & Other Slant Flush Valves

Wolverine Brass 57733 Big Orange II Hard Plastic Flapper, Orange

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper without Adapter

Black Rubber Replacement Flapper For Crane

Blue Vinyl Ultra Blue Star Flapper for Coast

Korky Original Toilet Flapper

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye 501P21 Red Microban Dura-Flush Flapper, 2" Valve Opening

Korky Flapper 16X- 1.6 Tank

Rubber Universal Flapper and Chain without Adapter

Rubber Universal Flapper with Adapter

"Tuff-Flex" Rubber Premium Flapper with Adapter

71706 Blue Rubber Flapper Replacement Positive Seal Ring For Kohler/Coast

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye Adjust-A-Flush B502P10 Thermoplastic Flapper

Fluidmaster Bull's Eye B501LP10 Thermoplastic Super Flapper without Adapter

Hydro-Force Silicone Rubber Adjustable Premium Flapper